Best Pie Places in NYC

Best Pie Places in NYC

Pie, pie, pie… This is actually one of the most loved desserts of all time, especially during the holidays. But there are some who actually just can’t get through their usual day without a slice of their favorite pie. So, what makes pie very much loved? The first thing you need to consider if you wish to get the best pie is its crust. It should be buttery and flaky. The filling follows. It should be not that sweet but it should have all the flavor it needs. Read on and we will share with you some of the best pie places here in NYC today.

Here are the best pie places in NYC


The first best pie places here in NYC on our list is the Petee’s. You will surely love their place even if it often crowded with pie lovers. Just make sure to order their every famous Slice Cream with its three scoops of vanilla ice cream to go along with it. This treat will surely hit home. It is one of the best pie here in NYC today. So, better check out this place while you are here in NYC.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

Established in 2009, this amazing pie place has gathered amazing reviews when it comes to their pies. You will surely love their Salty Honey slice since this is one of the best pie here in NYC. Better pair it up with a cup of tea or coffee. The perfect pie especially when you are broken and feeling down. It will certainly brighten up your day and mood. Two thumbs up for this amazing pie place here in NYC.


This place is often bustling with tourists and locals having their pie treat. If you wish to fully enjoy their great selection of pie and creams then better check out the place during the fewer peak hours. You will get to enjoy the pie and the place itself. This one of the best pie places here in NYC today.

Daly Pie

If you are looking for a pie with a twist then better check out this place. You will surely love their selections of pie especially the Case of the Mondays. This pie has peanut butter, chocolate, Nutella, and bits of salty potato chips for that balanced tasty pie treat ever. You will surely find the place packed with pie lovers during the day so better check out the place in mid-afternoon and enjoy their pie as well as coffee.


Choosing the best pie should not be that hard. You will find selections of such treats here in NYC. One of the best pie places here in NYC is the Houseman. One of their bestseller pies is the peanut butter beauty which you will get the best and gooiest pie ever with tang zest of sour cream. The best pie during rainy seasons. So, better check out this place today and you will surely love their offered pie selections.

Rockaway Beach Bakery

Banana crème is one of the best and most ordered pies here in this amazing place. They also serve the best coffee and wine in NYC. In fact, you will surely love the place itself. No wonder more and more locals and tourists keep coming back here at Rockaway Beach Bakery. They serve the best pie ever. So, if you and your friends are looking for a place to spend the lazy afternoon, be it this place. You will never go wrong with it, from the food, wine and the place itself. Two thumbs up indeed!

Abu’s Bakery

Now if you are in search of the best Navy bean pie then this is the perfect place to be. In fact, they are the only pie place here in NYC that serve such kind of pie. You will surely love their rich custard with a sweet, cinnamony crumble. They are also known for their Coconut Custard and Pecan pies. The best pie place for you and your friends. You will also buy more of their pie to take home to your family, for sure. The perfect to share a kind of pie.

Gramercy Tavern

The best Lime Meringue pie here in NYC will be easily obtained here at Gramercy Tavern. It may be a bit pricey but once you have tasted it, you will surely buy another one. The sweet and tangy taste of the lemon is very much balanced you will surely give it two thumbs up!

Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter